It’s Like We Were Still At School

Annual appraisals were never something that I enjoyed doing, back when I used to work for a living.

Of course, since retiring, it’s something I no longer have to do and I can look forward to the end of March now, rather than with the dread that used to fill me as that time approached.

I’ve worked for a number of companies in my time and never have I felt that the annual appraisal system was fit for purpose. I would have to spend hours making shit up about what individual members of my team did well and what they didn’t do so well at.  And then I’d have to try and make it sound different to the shit that I’d made up the previous year… but with it still being, obstensibly, exactly the same shit.

And I know that the guys under me all felt the same way.  All apart from one. There’s always one. Yes, I’m talking about you Nick… if you’re reading this. Which I’m pretty sure you’re not.

And why did I think they were a waste of time?  Because it was just an exercise. Something that HR would push so that they could tick a box to say they were showing due diligence to the employees.  It was never linked to salary, so over-performing or under-performing never resulted in any sort of financial recompence or penalty.  So, where’s the inspiration or motivation?

And. if someone is under-performing, it shouldn’t be left to the end of the year and then marked down on their annual appraisal. It should be discussed with them throughout the year, with coaching and regular catchups scheduled in to help them improve.  And the targets given should be sensible, realistic and achievable.

In my experience, that hardly ever happened.

And, of course, I’ve always held the same disain for my own appraisals and I’ve never attempted to hide that from any of my bosses.  I remember walking in to my manager’s office some years ago, for my annual assessment.  I sat down in front of him and looked down at the form on his desk, with my name on the top, then raised my eyes to meet his gaze. He too looked down at the form and then looked back at me.  With a heavy sigh, he picked up the form, tore it in half and dropped it in the wastepaper basket next to his desk. “Let’s just have a chat”, he said with a smile.
Top bloke.

As I say, it’s something I no longer need to worry about, so I really have no idea where this rant has come from.  It’s certainly not what I had intended to write this morning.
Oh well.

7/10 Masher tries hard, but often loses focus.

7 thoughts on “It’s Like We Were Still At School”

  1. We have stopped having them at present but I’m sure they will return at some point. These are part of the great cycle of workplace fads.
    The truth, as you imply, is that it never made any difference to anyone other than occasionally really passing someone off because the marking “profile” meant someone has to put on coaching plan by a the manager who had less idea of how to do the job than the guilty person.

    • I remember reading that appraisals should always take place in a comfortable environment, allowing the manager and the employee to have an unhurried and productive conversation.
      Mick H once did my appraisal in my van, in a layby on the A41, in the pouring rain.

      I wonder if it was the same layby where Gillian Taylforth did her… erm, appraisal.

  2. Yep, with you on this. When not linked to pay or benefits, what’s the point? My over performers over performed. My under performers were told to buck their ideas up, but nothing really happened. Performance plans n ever worked and I was too busy to sit on someone’s shoulder and micro mentor their every waking moment. Pointless

Comments are closed.